by P.T. Michelle
Read: September 2012
Published: July 9, 2012, self-published
Source: Kindle purchase
Category: YA Paranormal Romance
Series: Book 2 Brightest Kind of Darkness
Once Nara combines her prophetic ability with Ethan’s power to outsmart Fate at his own deadly cat-and-mouse game, she’s more determined than ever to help Ethan learn the meaning behind the raven sword tattoo that suddenly appeared on his back after their confrontation with Fate.
During her quest to uncover the tattoo’s secrets, Nara enlists the help of some new friends and discovers her own surprising connection to Ethan.
While Nara digs deeper into the mystery, her desire for answers leads her down a dangerous path full of powerful and ruthless enemies. Swept into an age-old battle, Nara quickly learns that keeping one’s enemies close can be a necessary evil, making an intangible enemy she can control far more preferable to the human enemies she can’t. (from Goodreads)
Lucid is the second book in P.T. Michelle's Brightest Kind of Darkness series. I loved the first book, but didn't review it. If you're new to this series, check out Asheley from Into the Hall of Book's thoughts HERE. I will recap some of Brightest Kind of Darkness. Be warned of SPOILERS if you haven't read it yet.
In Brightest Kind of Darkness (BKoD) we meet Nara Collins. Every night she dreams exactly what is going to happen to her the following day. Nara has been dreaming her future for so long that it is normal for her. She also knows she's not supposed to interfere in the events she sees. But when Nara dreams about a school bombing that will hurt her friends, she decides to take action and change her future. Her decision sets in motion the events on BKoD, which culminate in a battle with fate that she ultimately wins (for now).
We also meet Ethan Harris in BKoD, a boy who for some reason never shows up in Nara's dreams. He has his own powers, absorbing people's dark thoughts and nightmares when he comes into physical contact with anyone. He also has a large raven sword tattoo on his back, which inexplicably showed up one day on its own. Because of the darkness of his "ability," Ethan was loner until he meets Nara (I love that there is a very concrete reason why he originally comes across as a broody bad-boy). Although Ethan and Nara's powers are different they also compliment each other. The two of them make a great team, and Ethan sees Nara as a bright light (Sunshine) in the darkness he is constantly facing. In BKoD they build a friendship that turns romantic, and in Lucid they are a definitely couple.
However, when Lucid begins, Ethan has gone home to Michigan to fix his relationship with his parents, which fell apart when he began to get his powers. An admirable task, if that's what he was actually doing (I'm skeptical - you'll have to read the book to form your own opinion. It's too much of a spoiler to talk about why I think that).
With Ethan gone, Nara meets Drystan an exchange student who is also drawn to Nara. He practices parkour, has a hot accent and an ability of his own. Though I didn't like that Ethan was gone so much of Lucid, I really liked getting to know Drystan. But before you think this is going the way of the dreaded love triangle, it is clear through the book who Nara is in love with, and so far I am not worried. Drystan encourages Nara to learn self defense and seems to be a more open person than either Ethan or Nara. He also provides some great romantic tension.
While I did enjoy Lucid, I had some problems with the story. Also, with Ethan gone for most of the book and with few of the many lingering questions answered, it very much felt like an interlude in the overall story arc. Nara especially got on my nerves in this book. Several bad things happen to her, and it is clear that they are connected. But she just keeps going off on her own and not telling anyone about it. I like that Nara's her own person, but I don't like when characters take unnecessary risks and keep crucial information from each other.
In Lucid we get a lot of similar plot elements as the first book, especially in terms of Nara tempting fate by changing future events. And she spends a great deal of time researching ravens. While some of that was interesting, I honestly didn't understand how researching the bird would help Ethan figure out what was going on with his tattoo. However, I do get that for Nara it was also about staying connected to him.
Too many people were keeping secrets in this story, especially Nara from Ethan and Ethan from Nara. At the end of Lucid we are left with a lot of questions, and several new plot lines, but not many answers. I wish a few more elements had been cleared up before new questions were introduced.
Despite my problems with Lucid, there are some great moments in this story (don't worry, Ethan and Nara's relationship does heat up a notch) and several interesting revelations. I love Ethan and Nara as a pair, and am eager to see how Drystan plays into the mix (as long as that doesn't mean a triangle). I hope the next book features answers, instead of more questions. Also, Ethan and Nara need to be more honest with each other for their relationship to move forward. Hopefully, the secrets they've been keeping (ahem Ethan), don't hurt their relationship in the future. Even with my reservations about Lucid, I can't wait to get my hands on the next book in the series!
Cliffhanger Scale: Mild/Medium, No mortal danger, relationships are settled. But LOTS of questions left unanswered.
Love Triangle Factor: None so far (hope it stays that way!)
Rating: 3 stars*
*I still love the series, there ARE some good moments in here, and I have high hopes for the next book.
I haven't read this series (or actually even heard of it before strangely enough), but you have me intrigued, Lauren. I feel as if the second book is usually the weakest, so perhaps I'll wait to see what you think of the third novel before picking up this series. It sounds very good though, so onto my TBR-List it goes! ;) Wonderful review, dear! :)ReplyDelete
That's very true. The second book is often the weakest, unfortunately. However, I do remember the author saying that this one was supposed to be a novella but she just kept adding content until it was a novel. I wish it had stayed a shorter book. Would have been better! But still great series!Delete
I actually wish the third book was already out. I feel like I'm sort of hanging, waiting on Ethan to reveal himself. This is one of the worst things about reading series that aren't completed.
Didn't you, in all of our emails and ramblings, tell me you thought this would possibly be a four-book series?
You know, I was thinking too (again), and I want Nara to play more soccer again. *random I know, but I liked it*
I do too. I wish I'd waited until the third book was out to read this one. Ugh incomplete series are really becoming a problem for me lately! And YES. I'm pretty sure I asked the author in a tweet how many books it would be and she said probably 4 books. I'm not sure how far ahead she's planned it. And with all the possible plot directions in this one, I don't see how it could possibly be just 3 books. Also, remember that this was originally supposed to be a short novella between the other books. Which it still feels like - although a looonnnnngggg one.Delete
YES! I also liked her playing soccer. Is it just that the season is over in this one? Is soccer in the fall?
Soccer IS in the fall, but look at the cover. And there IS a place in the book where soccer is mentioned, but I don't think they ever revisit it. I suppose it is because that is an Ethan-and-Nara thing (remember, they played together frequently). I guess Drystan and Nara needed their own thing, but still. I liked the soccer. Random.Delete