by Juliet Marillier
Read: November 9-13, 2012
Published: October 2, 2009 by Tor
Source: Kindle purchase
Category: Fantasy/Fairytale retelling (Adult with crossover YA appeal)
Whistling Tor is a place of secrets and mystery. Surrounded by a wooded hill, and unknown presences, the crumbling fortress is owned by a chieftain whose name is spoken throughout the district in tones of revulsion and bitterness. A curse lies over Anluan's family and his people; those woods hold a perilous force whose every whisper threatens doom.
For young scribe Caitrin it is a safe haven. This place where nobody else is prepared to go seems exactly what she needs, for Caitrin is fleeing her own demons. As Caitlin comes to know Anluan and his home in more depth she realizes that it is only through her love and determination that the curse can be broken and Anluan and his people set free. (From Goodreads)
Heart's Blood reminds me of how much I love Juliet Marillier's novels. I love that they are steeped in Irish history - this story takes place around the time of the Norman invasions - but they also have a unique fantasy element that works seamlessly in the Irish culture. Besides the way Marillier mixes history and magic in her stories, I adore her strong heroines and unlikely heroes.
I got excited when I realized that Heart's Blood is a fairytale retelling, because Marillier excels at retellings (If you haven't read Daughter of the Forest, go get it now.). The basic story structure of Beauty and the Beast is clearly visible in Heart's Blood, but it is also uniquely Marillier's storytelling. She takes much loved tales, crafts them into her own stories, and in the process draws out so much human emotion.
Heart's Blood follows the story of Caitrin, a girl who, when the story begins, is on the run from an abusive past. She seeks employment at Whistling Tor, a fortress surrounded in deep mystery and suspicion. Where rumors of curses, danger and a host of inhuman inhabitants circulate.
Anlaun is the Tor's chieftain. Crippled by a deformity, he is in desperate need of Caitrin's abilities as a scribe. Caitrin needs the remote setting of his home to hide from those who want to harm her. But Anlaun's appearance and the secrets that he holds have made him as distrustful of outsiders as they are of him, and he comes across as cold at first. Caitrin is determined to be brave in her new - and strange - home. But she has been beaten down by recent circumstances and is wary of the hostile nature of her new employer. Despite the magic in this story, Marillier's characters have very human struggles and flaws.
What I've always loved about this fairytale is the fact that Beauty comes to love the Beast not in spite of who he is, but because of it. That is no more apparent than in Marillier's story. Caitrin and Anlaun are both strong people, but they also have an innate vulnerability because of what they have faced in their lives. It is not surprising that their own personal struggles within themselves are just as important as what they face from the outside. Caitrin and Anlaun are a fantastic pair. Despite how different they appear on the surface, they compliment each other well. I love that Marillier pairs people who seem very unlikely at first glance but who make perfect sense on a deeper level.
In addition to Caitrin and Anlaun, this book has a unique and colorful supporting cast that is one of my favorite parts of this story. There are no talking teapots, but these characters bring both a lightness to the book and serve to highlight the mystery and desperation of the place. The setting of Whistling Tor also has a great atmospheric quality to it that made it feel like a living presence in the story.
What broke down for me about Heart's Blood were some of the details of the plot. Most specifically, I thought it was clear early on who/what is the villain in the story, but it took a long time for the characters to put it together. Certain things were observed by them, but I became frustrated with how long it took for them to connect the dots, or for anyone to ask any questions.
Although Heart's Blood has so many of the elements that I love of Mariller's stories, it still didn't capture the magic of Daughter of the Forest or Son of the Shadows for me. However, I still did enjoy this book and will certainly be back for more from this world.
Cliffhanger Scale: None (Marillier's series are generally all companion books)
Love Triangle Factor: None
Rating: 4 stars
I'm so glad you enjoyed this one, Lauren! Like you, I had minor qualms with the plot but the love story and rich lore as a whole completely won me over. I just love Anluan and Caitrin - I could read about them forever! Lovely review!(:ReplyDelete
I love these two as well! LOVE Marillier's subtle love stories. I hope she writes more about Whistling Tor.Delete
I love the way you're breezing through Mariller's books. I'm still basking in the loveliness of Daughter of the Forest. She is so prolific, though - it'll take me a lifetime to finish all of her work if it is so enjoyable. I do wish I had known about her sooner! Great review. :)ReplyDelete
HA! I've only read 3 of her books. You should see the authors I HAVE breezed through. But I do get the point that once they're all done, it's rather sad:(. Thankfully, as you say, Marillier is quite prolific and is still writing.Delete
Of the many Marillier novels I've read, I definitely do believe that her Sevenwaters novels are by far her strongest and just overall her best. I did also enjoy Heart's Blood. It just wasn't quite the retelling I was expecting (maybe I'm being more critical of it being Beauty and the Beast vs Daughter of the Forest being The Six Swans because I was aware of the former's comparison and am far more familiar with that tale). It is definitely a more melancholy and atmospheric story, but it's a beautiful one too!ReplyDelete
I agree! Sevenwaters is definitely the best of Marillier I've read so far. But I'm thankful that she's such a prolific writer, so there is always more to discover. I get what you're saying about Beauty and The Beast vs. The Six Swans. I am definitely more familiar with this story. And atmospheric is a great way to describe this story.Delete
Gah, I have GOT to pick one of her books up. I consistently hear wonderful things about them. Wish my library carried them:/ Anyway of all the fairy tales Beauty and the Beast ranks way up there on my list of faves. Maybe I can get a copy of this and read it AND Robin McKinley's "Beauty" and review both together:)ReplyDelete
But no talking teapots, really? That's a damn shame;)
YES YES. Start with Daughter of the Forest!! BUT I also like the idea of doing Beauty comparisons. I've also not read the Robin McKinley version, though I've heard a lot about that one.Delete
Gah! EVERY time I read a review for this book I get so utterly excited for the day when I will pick this book up. I love Beauty and the Beast for the same reason you stated--she learns to love him not in spite of who he is, but because of it. Who could possible capture and retell that feeling better then Marillier?! Lovely lovely review, Lauren, even if it's not quite DotF or SotS, I know I'm going to adore this one.ReplyDelete
You need to read this one, Heidi!! I hope you love it.Delete